Can You Paint Vinyl Shutters? What Colors Are Recommended?

VU Window Treatments
Oct 18, 2024
4 min read

Updated: Apr 18

TLDR;

Yes, you can paint vinyl shutters—just make sure to use vinyl-safe, acrylic latex paint and avoid dark colors unless the paint is specifically formulated to resist heat. Recommended colors include timeless shades like white and navy, as well as trending tones like sage green and taupe for a durable and updated look.

Why Homeowners Are Painting Vinyl Shutters in 2025

Vinyl shutters are popular because they’re low-maintenance, affordable, and enhance curb appeal. But as styles change and colors fade, many homeowners are choosing to paint instead of replace them.

Here’s why painting is on the rise:

Updating the style to match siding or trim
Refreshing faded or discolored shutters
Boosting curb appeal on a budget

Types of vinyl shutters include:

Standard shutters (hinged and functional)
Decorative shutters (fixed and non-functional)

Both can be painted successfully with the right prep and paint.

Can Vinyl Shutters Be Painted?

Yes, vinyl shutters can be painted—even though many believe they can’t. The key is surface prep and using the correct type of paint.

Important things to know:

Vinyl is slick and needs cleaning or light sanding for paint to adhere
It expands and contracts with temperature changes, so flexible paint is essential
Don’t paint if the vinyl is cracked, brittle, or warped
Always check your shutter manufacturer’s warranty before painting

What Kind of Paint Should You Use on Vinyl Shutters?

The paint you choose makes or breaks your project. Using the wrong kind can lead to peeling, warping, and bubbling.

Use:

100% acrylic latex paint
Paints labeled “vinyl-safe” or “vinyl-safe formula”

Recommended brands:

Sherwin-Williams VinylSafe
Behr Marquee Exterior
Benjamin Moore Regal Select Exterior

Primer is optional if repainting in a similar color. Use a primer if switching to a drastically different shade or painting over a glossy surface.

Avoid:

Oil-based paint
Standard dark paint (unless it’s labeled vinyl-safe)

Recommended Colors for Vinyl Shutters in 2025

Choosing the right color is critical. Dark colors absorb heat and may warp vinyl unless you’re using specially formulated paint. Stick to lighter or mid-tones unless the product says it’s vinyl-safe.

Trending in 2025:

Sage green
Soft taupe
Dusty blue
Warm gray
Charcoal (vinyl-safe only)

Classic and timeless:

White – clean and heat-reflective
Black – striking and traditional (use only vinyl-safe black)
Navy – elegant and works with many styles

Regional color ideas:

Coastal: sand, sky blue, white
Urban: slate, deep green, charcoal
Farmhouse/Craftsman: olive, barn red, brown

Pro tip: Use a color visualization tool to preview different shutter colors before painting.

How to Paint Vinyl Shutters Without Removing Them

You don’t have to take shutters down to paint them. Painting in place is easier and faster if you prep properly.

Step-by-step:

Clean thoroughly using TSP or a vinegar and water solution
Lightly sand the surface for better adhesion
Apply primer if needed (especially for color changes)
Use a brush for control or spray paint for a smooth finish
Apply two light coats and let each dry completely
Check your work for coverage and consistency

Can You Paint Vinyl Shutters Black?

Yes, but with caution. Standard black paint absorbs too much heat and can warp the material. Only use vinyl-safe or heat-reflective black paint, and avoid painting in direct sunlight.

Black works best:

On shaded sides of the house
On brick or stone homes for bold contrast

Repainting Vinyl Shutters: What You Need to Know

You can absolutely repaint shutters that have already been painted. Stick to the same or similar color when possible to reduce stress on the material.

Benefits of repainting:

Extends shutter life by 5–7 years
Saves money versus replacing
Keeps your home looking fresh

Touch-up small areas as needed, or repaint completely for a full refresh.

Painting vs. Replacing Vinyl Shutters

Painting is almost always more affordable than replacing, especially if your shutters are still structurally sound.

Cost comparison:

Painting: $15–$40 per shutter
Replacing: $60–$120 per shutter

When to replace:

If shutters are cracked, broken, warped, or permanently faded
If the style or size no longer fits your home’s look

Caring for Painted Vinyl Shutters

Painted vinyl shutters are easy to maintain with just a little attention.

Maintenance tips:

Clean once or twice a year with mild soap and water
Avoid high-pressure washers or harsh chemicals
Touch up any chips or scratches as they appear
Plan to repaint every 5–7 years depending on sun exposure

Choosing Shutter Colors Based on Home Style

Shutter color can enhance your home’s architectural personality. If you're working with plantation shutters, here are tips for Styling Plantation Shutters to match both modern and traditional home designs.

Best color options by home style:

Colonial: black, forest green, navy
Craftsman/Farmhouse: olive, charcoal, barn red
Modern: slate, jet black (vinyl-safe only), greige
Beach Cottage: light blue, white, sandy beige

Matching the shutter color to your trim or front door creates a cohesive, well-designed look.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can vinyl shutters be painted?

Yes, with proper surface prep and vinyl-safe paint.

What paint is best for vinyl shutters? 100% acrylic latex or specially labeled vinyl-safe exterior paints.

Can you paint vinyl shutters black?

Yes, but only with heat-reflective vinyl-safe paint to prevent warping.

Do I need to remove shutters before painting?

No, they can be painted in place if prepped properly.

How long will paint last on vinyl shutters?

Expect 5–7 years depending on weather exposure and maintenance.

Will painting vinyl shutters void the warranty?

Check your shutter manufacturer’s terms—some warranties do not allow alterations.

Exterior Shutter Upgrades That Pay Off

Painting your vinyl shutters is an easy way to update your home’s exterior without spending a fortune. With the right paint, prep, and color choice, you can completely transform your home’s curb appeal.